top of page
Search

Potential Implications for CASPs Buisness Model arising for Regualtory Developments for the Week Ending 9 January

1. Executive Summary


The most critical impact on Business Models is the end of “regulatory arbitrage” regarding capital efficiency (EU/Global) and the confirmation of a strict “survival window” for UK market access. Simultaneously, Revenue Generation faces a sharp dichotomy: immediate compression in APAC (Hong Kong retail restrictions) and the US (potential yield bans), contrasted with new federal banking and derivative revenue pathways opening in the US.


2. Material Impacts on Business Models


Structural, operational, and market access changes are required to remain compliant.


A. Market Access & Existential Deadlines (UK & Thailand)


  • The UK “Survival Window” (Critical Risk): The FCA confirmed that the Authorisation Gateway will open in September 2026, with the full regime live by October 2027.

    • Business Model Impact: This creates a strict 9-month window (starting Sept’ 26) where firms must secure authorisation. The “transitional” model (operating under MLRs) is coming to an end. Firms unable to submit a complete FSMA-compliant dossier during this gateway face a forced market exit in Oct 2027.

  • Biometric Identity Threat (Regional Risk): The Thai SEC’s investigation into “iris scanning” projects threatens the viability of “Proof of Personhood” models (e.g., Worldcoin-style mechanics).

    • Business Model Impact: Models relying on biometric hardware for user acquisition face existential regulatory headwinds in SE Asia; if data collection is halted, the user acquisition funnel effectively breaks.


B. Capital Structure & Consolidation (EU & Global)


  • End of “Light-Touch” Subsidiaries (EU): New EBA guidelines (Jan 9) mandate that crypto subsidiaries of banking groups must be prudentially consolidated.

    • Business Model Impact: This eliminates the model of housing high-risk crypto activities in lightly capitalised subsidiaries. Bank-owned CASPs must now align with the parent bank’s risk appetite and capital buffers.

  • Branch Booking Restrictions (EU): New EBA standards on third-country branches (Jan 9) restrict remote booking.

    • Business Model Impact: Global CASPs using an EU “branch” model to book trades to an offshore HQ may be forced to “subsidiarise” (create a complete EU legal entity) to comply with new presence requirements.

  • Basel Capital Costs (Global): The Basel crypto standard (effective Jan 1) assigns a 1,250% risk weight to unbacked crypto assets.

    • Business Model Impact: Banking partners will immediately pass these capital costs down to CASPs. Reliance on a single banking partner is now a critical failure point, as banks may off-board crypto clients to preserve capital.


C. Federal Banking Pathway (USA)


  • Validating the Federal Charter: The OCC received a National Trust Bank application from World Liberty Financial (Jan 7).

    • Business Model Impact: This validates a federal model that bypasses state-by-state Money Transmitter Licensing (MTL). A federal charter grants direct access to Federal Reserve payment rails, significantly reducing counterparty risk and settlement friction.


D. Liability Standards (Global & Dubai)


  • Active Freezing Mandate (FATF): FATF validated the “T3” Financial Crime Unit model (active freezing of assets).

    • Business Model Impact: “Passive compliance” (filing SARs) is no longer sufficient. Issuers and exchanges must now demonstrate “active interdiction” capabilities to freeze illicit funds in real-time.

  • Liability Transfer (Dubai): The DFSA is abolishing its centralised token allowlist on Jan 12.

    • Business Model Impact: The regulator is transferring 100% of token suitability liability to the CASP. The business model shifts from “regulator-dependent” to “risk-owner.”


3. Material Impacts on Revenue Generation


Regulatory shifts affecting income streams, margins, and product viability.


A. Revenue Threats (Compression)


  • Retail Derivative Wipeout (Hong Kong): The SFC’s HK$4 million fine against Saxo Capital establishes strict liability for distributing complex products to retail users.

    • Revenue Impact: Immediate loss of high-margin retail trading volume (futures/options). Firms must technically segregate these products, restricting them to Professional Investors (PIs) only.

  • Stablecoin Yield Ban (USA): Senate markups scheduled for Jan 15 regarding the “Digital Asset Market Structure” bill focus on banning stablecoin pass-through yield.

    • Revenue Impact: If passed, this would eliminate “Staking-as-a-Service” and “Earn” products, which are primary recurring revenue drivers for US-facing platforms.


B. Revenue Opportunities (Expansion)


  • Regulated Prediction Markets (USA): The CFTC issued no-action relief (Jan 8) allowing Bitnomial to list “event contracts” (prediction markets).

    • Revenue Impact: Opens a compliant revenue stream for US exchanges to offer prediction products (e.g., political/economic binary swaps), a sector previously dominated by offshore entities.

  • Net Interest Margin Capture (USA): The federal charter pathway (OCC application) enables stablecoin issuers to capture the full Net Interest Margin (NIM) on reserves without dilution from third-party partner banks.

  • Listing Velocity (Dubai): By abolishing the token allowlist (Jan 12), the DFSA allows CASPs to list trending assets faster.

    • Revenue Impact: Faster speed-to-market allows firms to capture initial trading volume market share, provided they have robust internal due diligence to manage the increased liability.

  • Dual Listings (Singapore): MAS proposed a “Global Listing Board” for firms with a capitalisation of>S$2bn.

    • Revenue Impact: Provides mature CASPs with a pathway to dual-listings (US-SG), enabling access to deeper liquidity pools and potentially higher equity valuations.


4. Recommended Actions


  1. CFO: Re-model custody and hedging costs immediately, accounting for the new Basel 1,250% risk weighting; anticipate fee hikes from banking partners.

  2. Compliance (UK): Initiate a gap analysis for the September 2026 FCA Authorisation Gateway; this is a“survival” priority.

  3. Strategy (US): Prepare contingency plans for “Earn” products ahead of the Jan 15 Senate markup; simultaneously evaluate feasibility for launching CFTC-compliant prediction markets.

  4. Product (HK): Hard-code blocks for retail derivatives in Hong Kong to avoid enforcement.


 
 
 

Comments

bottom of page